Benjamin Moore and Sherwin-Williams are two of the most trusted paint brands, offering high-quality products with differences in pricing, availability, color options, and application. Sherwin-Williams is often preferred for its durability, ease of access, and professional appeal, while Benjamin Moore stands out for its color technology and eco-friendliness. Both brands offer a wide range of finishes and styles, making them suitable for different project needs.
Benjamin Moore vs. Sherwin-Williams: A Complete Breakdown
1. Brand Overview
- Sherwin-Williams: A globally recognized name with over 150 years of history. Its paints are widely used by contractors and professionals due to their durability and performance, with a focus on accessibility through dedicated Sherwin-Williams stores.
- Benjamin Moore: A similarly longstanding brand with a reputation for innovation, particularly in its eco-friendly offerings and advanced color-matching technology. It’s sold through independent retailers, allowing a more personalized shopping experience.
2. Price Points
- Sherwin-Williams: Generally more affordable, especially during their frequent sales and promotions. Ideal for those managing larger projects or looking to stretch their budget.
- Benjamin Moore: Typically priced higher, reflecting its emphasis on premium ingredients and color consistency. Appeals to homeowners seeking long-lasting finishes and rich, true colors.
3. Color Selection
- Sherwin-Williams: Offers over 1,700 colors, with tools like the ColorSnap® Visualizer that make it easier to select shades. Their colors are optimized for versatile projects and lighting conditions.
- Benjamin Moore: Renowned for its depth of color, including its proprietary Gennex® waterborne colorant technology. Colors like those in the Aura® and Regal® Select lines are prized for their richness and subtle undertones.
4. Availability
- Sherwin-Williams: Found in Sherwin-Williams-owned stores, which ensures consistent stock and access to their full line. More accessible for contractors and frequent buyers.
- Benjamin Moore: Sold exclusively through independent dealers. While this may mean fewer locations, these retailers often provide expert advice tailored to your project.
5. Eco-Friendliness
- Sherwin-Williams: Features low-VOC (volatile organic compound) paints like Harmony® and SuperPaint®, with a focus on reducing indoor air pollutants.
- Benjamin Moore: Leads the charge in eco-friendly paints with products like Natura® (discontinued but replaced by newer green lines) and Regal® Select, known for being zero-VOC even after tinting.
6. Paint Performance and Application
- Sherwin-Williams: Known for ease of application and durability, with a slight edge in exterior paint performance. Lines like Emerald® and Duration® are ideal for high-traffic areas or outdoor projects.
- Benjamin Moore: Offers superior coverage with fewer coats, particularly in premium lines like Aura®. Their paints are also noted for smoother finishes and excellent adherence.
7. Customer and Professional Preference
- Sherwin-Williams: Often favored by professionals for its consistency and availability. Contractors appreciate the dedicated customer support, rewards programs, and trade discounts.
- Benjamin Moore: Appeals more to homeowners and designers due to its high-end feel and exclusive distribution model.
8. Durability and Maintenance
- Sherwin-Williams: Excels in long-term durability, particularly for exterior applications. Its paints are highly resistant to weathering, fading, and peeling.
- Benjamin Moore: Offers similar durability, with a focus on smooth finishes and washability. Interior options like Scuff-X® are popular for their resistance to wear and tear.
Final Thoughts for Customers
At Colin Can Help, we understand why Sherwin-Williams might be your top pick—it’s a durable, accessible, and cost-effective solution for most projects. However, for customers who prioritize eco-friendliness or a broader palette of sophisticated colors, Benjamin Moore may be worth the investment. Either way, both brands guarantee professional-quality results, so the choice comes down to personal preferences, project needs, and budget.